Difference between revisions of "Communications/Chat Investigations"
From Makers Local 256
(Put together a page listing the pros and cons of a few chat platforms a few of us have been trialing.) |
m (Added note about IRC bridges.) |
||
| Line 40: | Line 40: | ||
* Custom channels for project or event planning | * Custom channels for project or event planning | ||
* Easy private channels and group messages | * Easy private channels and group messages | ||
| + | * Weechat plugin exists that lets you connect to Slack through Weechat IRC client over official API | ||
Cons: | Cons: | ||
* Not open source | * Not open source | ||
| Line 45: | Line 46: | ||
* Requires an account with Slack | * Requires an account with Slack | ||
* May not be around/free forever | * May not be around/free forever | ||
| + | Other Notes: | ||
| + | * Can set up a bridge to IRC if you want/need to use IRC to connect | ||
== Mattermost == | == Mattermost == | ||
| Line 52: | Line 55: | ||
Pros: | Pros: | ||
| − | |||
* Open source | * Open source | ||
* Easy-to-install self-hosting | * Easy-to-install self-hosting | ||
| Line 72: | Line 74: | ||
* Scrolling in web app requires click "load more messages" | * Scrolling in web app requires click "load more messages" | ||
* Other minor usability quirks | * Other minor usability quirks | ||
| + | Other Notes: | ||
| + | * Can set up a bridge to IRC if you want/need to use IRC to connect | ||
Latest revision as of 17:42, 16 March 2018
ML256 has historically used IRC and Email as its main methods of virtual communication. Recently, many new platforms have evolved out desires for simpler, more powerful chat applications that can make communication easier and more accessible. This page lists a couple of the platforms we have tried out and notes about each.
IRC
Server: Freenode
Channels: #makerslocal (official), others for off-topic conversations
Pros:
- Completely free
- Clients are almost always open-source
- We have a few helpful bots already set up and running
- Will likely be around forever
- Account not required
- Can embed on a webpage
- We don't have to host anything
- A large chunk of members are already using it
Cons:
- Hard to get into the IRC ecosystem
- No persistence unless you set up a server to bounce through or pay for a 3rd party service
- No mobile notifications unless you set up a server or pay for 3rd party service
- Netsplit issues
- Confusing mechanisms like NickServ
- No support for images built-in
Slack
Server: https://makerslocal256.slack.com
Channels: #general, #publicity, #design, #projects, #random, etc
Pros:
- Free Slack instance because we're a non-profit
- Clean, easy-to-use interface
- Wonderful mobile app and web apps
- Emoji reaction support
- Built-in image/video/gif support
- Strong integration support 1st party and 3rd party
- Easy sign-up via invite or auto-inviter page
- Easy custom slash-commands for ML256
- Well-known and popular
- Custom channels for project or event planning
- Easy private channels and group messages
- Weechat plugin exists that lets you connect to Slack through Weechat IRC client over official API
Cons:
- Not open source
- Blocked at some workplaces (workarounds exist)
- Requires an account with Slack
- May not be around/free forever
Other Notes:
- Can set up a bridge to IRC if you want/need to use IRC to connect
Mattermost
Server: chat.crump.space (Temporary)
Channels: same as Slack
Pros:
- Open source
- Easy-to-install self-hosting
- Emoji reaction support
- Built-in image/video/gif support
- Decent integration support
- Easy sign-up via invite or built-in signup page
- Easy custom slash-commands for ML256
- Easy private channels and group messages
- Markdown messages
- CLI that would allow us to provision accounts
- Custom channels for project or event planning
Cons:
- Admins have access to all private channels and messages between users
- Non-zero cost of maintaining the server
- Mobile app isn't great, lacks features, fails quietly
- Properly encrypted and delivered notifications require ML256 to build and distribute iPhone and Android apps
- Integrations are a pain to set up
- Scrolling in web app requires click "load more messages"
- Other minor usability quirks
Other Notes:
- Can set up a bridge to IRC if you want/need to use IRC to connect
